Last lesson ended with a paradox. Potential flow gave the light-aircraft analog a lift of N/m and a drag of exactly zero, for every shape, because drag’s work had nowhere to go. The culprit is the condition potential flow dropped: it lets air slide along the skin, while real air sticks (no-slip, 11.4 Viscosity & the Navier–Stokes Equations). Ludwig Prandtl’s answer (1904, from memory): at high Reynolds number viscosity matters only in a boundary layer, a sheet so thin that potential flow is right outside it, while inside it no-slip drags the speed down to zero at the wall. Friction drag lives in that sheet; when it tears off the surface, so do pressure drag and stall. Its profile is a boundary value problem on an infinite domain, solved by the shooting of 8.1 Two-Point Boundary Value Problems.
Tools: 11.5 Non-dimensionalization & the Reynolds Number, 11.4 Viscosity & the Navier–Stokes Equations, 11.7 Potential Flow & Stream Functions and 8.1 Two-Point Boundary Value Problems.
Transcript
- Last lesson ended on a paradox. Potential flow gave the wing lift and exactly zero drag, d'Alembert's paradox, because it lets air slide along the skin. Real air sticks. Ludwig Prandtl's answer, in 1904: at high Reynolds number, viscosity matters only in a thin boundary layer hugging the surface. Outside it, potential flow is right. Inside it, the speed falls to zero at the wall.
- No-slip pins the air at the wall, and the speed climbs to the outer stream across a thickness delta, far smaller than the length L. Balance inertia, U squared over L, against viscosity, nu U over delta squared, and delta over L scales like Reynolds number to the minus one half. And the pressure does not change across the layer: the outer flow impresses it.
- On a flat plate there is no length but x, so the profile is one shape, stretched by the square root of nu x over U. With eta the scaled height and a stream function, the partial differential equation collapses to the Blasius equation: f triple prime plus a half f f double prime equals zero. At the wall, f and f prime are zero. Far away, f prime equals one.
- That is a boundary value problem, so we shoot. Guess the wall slope f double prime of zero, integrate with RK4, and measure the miss in f prime at the far end. Starting from 0.2, the profile undershoots. From 0.5, it overshoots. The secant method steers between them, and in six steps lands on 0.332057, with f prime reaching one.
- But infinity is not on the grid. End the domain at eta equals 6 and you get 0.332566. At 8, 0.332059. At 10 and 12, seven digits agree, because f double prime dies like a Gaussian. And one shot with slope 1 ends at f prime equals 2.085409. Rescale it: 2.085409 to the minus three halves is 0.332057336. No iteration needed.
- Read the layer off the profile. F prime reaches 0.99 at eta equals 4.910: delta ninety-nine is 4.910 x over root Reynolds x. Displacement thickness is 1.7208, momentum thickness 0.6641, in the same units. The wall slope gives skin friction: C f equals 0.664 over the square root of Reynolds x. It is largest at the front, where the layer is thinnest.
- Now the wing: a 1.5 metre chord at 50 metres per second. Reynolds number 5.135 times ten to the sixth. If the layer stayed laminar, it would be 3.250 millimetres thick at the trailing edge, and rub 2.693 newtons per metre off both faces: where d'Alembert's drag went, a momentum deficit in a thin sheet. But transition starts near Reynolds x of 5 times ten to the fifth, at only 0.1461 metres. So 2.693 is a lower bound.
- Now the pressure gradient. Behind the suction peak the pressure rises: an adverse gradient. At the wall, mu u yy equals p e prime, so the profile bends the wrong way and grows an inflection. Falkner-Skan makes it exact: edge speed K x to the m, with m a dial. Set the wall shear to zero and shoot on m: separation at m equals minus 0.090429, beta minus 0.19884. The edge speed may drop only 6.08 percent per doubling of distance.
- Past that point near-wall air flows backwards and the layer lifts off. On a wing that is stall: circulation and lift fall, and drag jumps. A laminar layer tolerates almost no slowing; a turbulent one holds on far longer, which is why dimples help a golf ball. Next, 11.9: past Reynolds x around 5 times ten to the fifth, the layer turns turbulent.
Prandtl’s idea
11.5 showed the trap. The viscous term carries , and the light wing has , so dropping it looks safe. But dropping the highest derivative loses a boundary condition: Euler can enforce “no flow through the wall”, not “no slip along it”. The escape: near the wall the velocity changes over a distance , so second derivatives there are of size , and viscosity rejoins the balance.
Prandtl’s split:
- Outside: 11.7’s potential flow. It sets the edge speed and, through Bernoulli, the pressure .
- Inside: a thin layer where inertia and viscosity balance, taking as given and bringing the speed to zero at the wall.
The boundary-layer equations by scaling
Take steady 2D flow along a wall, along it and normal to it, with Navier–Stokes and continuity:
Inside the layer, changes over and over , and is of size . Continuity sets the size of : must cancel , so , small. Now size each term of the equation:
| term | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| size |
Both inertia terms are . is smaller than by : drop it. The layer exists because the surviving viscous term balances inertia:
11.5’s estimate, now with a mechanism. In the equation every term is smaller by , so , and the pressure changes across the layer by about : a part in for the wing. So the pressure does not change across the layer: , impressed by the outer flow, where Bernoulli gives . What remains is
with on the wall and at the edge.
The flat plate: a similarity solution
On a flat plate in a uniform stream, and the pressure term vanishes. There is no length in the problem except itself, and 11.4’s Stokes problem had the same feature: its profile was one shape stretched by . Here the analog of is , so try one shape stretched by :
The stream function makes continuity automatic. The chain rule, with and , gives
Substituting, the pieces of and cancel, leaving . Every term carries , which divides out:
This is the Blasius equation (1908, from memory). is no-slip, is no flow through the wall, joins the outer stream. A PDE became one ODE: every station’s profile is the same curve , stretched by .
Solving Blasius by shooting
Two conditions at , one at infinity: a BVP. Shooting guesses the missing initial value , integrates with RK4, and measures the miss
The lab (block A) does this with RK4, , and the secant method from and ; it converges in six steps to
The infinite domain, honestly. We cannot integrate to infinity, so we impose at . That is a modelling error; to size it, move :
| 6 | 8 | 10 | 12 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
From on, seven digits stop moving. Why so fast, and why is shooting safe here when it failed on in 8.1? Write the equation as , which integrates to
Far out , so dies like a Gaussian, roughly . No growing mode can swamp the answer, and by the neglected tail is invisible in the 7th digit.
The profile’s numbers (lab block A; the plate panel prints the first two):
- 99% thickness: at , so , with . The textbook "".
- Displacement thickness: (it is ): the slowed air pushes the outer flow away as if the body were thicker by .
- Momentum thickness: , the lost momentum as a thickness. Its coefficient equals : next section.
Skin friction and the drag of a plate
The wall shear is . Divide by , using :
Friction is largest at the leading edge, where the layer is thinnest. Per metre of span, over one face of length :
Where d’Alembert’s drag went. A box around the plate loses momentum flux per face through the trailing-edge station (von Kármán’s momentum balance, stated), and with the lab’s that is exactly . The missing drag is a momentum deficit in a millimetre-thin sheet, carried off in the wake.
Worked example: the light wing’s laminar layer
A m chord at m/s in sea-level air ( m/s, kg/m, as in 11.5). Model each face as a flat plate (a thin wing at small incidence nearly is).
- , so .
- If the layer stayed laminar to the trailing edge: mm and mm.
- Wall shear at the trailing edge: Pa, .
- Friction drag, two faces: N/m. Against 11.7’s lift of N/m, that is .
Does it stay laminar? No. A smooth plate in a quiet stream starts transition near (from memory; roughness, noise and pressure gradients move it), reached at m, under a tenth of the chord, where mm. Behind it the layer turns turbulent, so N/m is a lower bound, not the wing’s friction drag (11.9).
Slide down to m/s: drops tenfold, the layer is times thicker, and the transition line moves back to m, nearly the trailing edge. Below m/s it leaves the plate.
Pressure gradients and separation
On a wing’s upper surface the air speeds up over the nose (, pressure falling: favourable), then slows behind the suction peak toward the trailing edge (, pressure rising: adverse). 11.7’s cylinder is the extreme: from on the shoulder back to .
The mechanism. Outside the layer, air climbs the pressure rise by trading kinetic energy for pressure. Inside, the same rise acts (pressure does not change across the layer), but near-wall air has already lost most of its kinetic energy to friction: it slows first, stops, and reverses. At the wall, where , the boundary-layer equation reads
An adverse gradient makes the profile curve the “wrong” way at the wall; since it must curve the usual way far out, it has an inflection point. As the gradient persists the wall slope is pushed to zero: zero wall shear, the separation point. Behind it near-wall air flows backwards, the layer lifts off, and the outer flow no longer follows the body.
Falkner–Skan: a family with a dial
To put numbers on this, take edge speeds . 11.7’s complex potential produces them: has , so the speed along the real axis is , the flow filling a corner of angle ( on both walls). With , the same substitution as Blasius (Problem 2) gives
is Blasius, a stagnation point, adverse. Tables quote Hartree’s (label from memory). At the wall, : the curvature result above.
For each the sim bisects on in ( increases with ). It prints at , at and at , where the profile has an inflection at . Separation is where the wall shear reaches zero, so set and shoot on instead, solving . Lab block C (secant) and the sim (bisection) find
with the same to five digits at and ( moves in its sixth decimal). That matches the tabulated (from memory). Below even overshoots: no attached similar solution exists.
How gentle is that? The edge speed drops only each time the distance doubles (): a corner of , a wall bending away by under . A laminar layer tolerates almost no deceleration.
Honest limits. Falkner–Skan layers are self-similar. On a real wing the gradient changes along the chord and separation depends on the layer’s history, found by marching (or integral methods such as Thwaites’, from memory). Falkner–Skan gives the picture and the order of magnitude, not a wing’s separation point.
Stall, and why golf balls have dimples
Stall. Raise a wing’s angle of attack and the suction peak near the nose deepens, so the climb back to trailing-edge pressure steepens. Past some angle the upper-surface layer separates. The Kutta condition that fixes the circulation (11.7, 12.1) assumes the flow leaves smoothly at the trailing edge; once it leaves earlier, circulation and lift fall and drag jumps. 12.1 sets ideal lift lines beside real ones, which bend over at stall. Given Falkner–Skan’s tiny tolerance, a laminar layer would separate soon behind the suction peak; the turbulent layer after transition holds on much longer (11.9), which is why wings work at useful angles.
Golf balls (qualitative, from memory). A smooth sphere at the golf ball’s (11.5) keeps a laminar layer that separates near its shoulder, leaving a wide low-pressure wake. Dimples trip the layer turbulent. Turbulent mixing brings fast outer air down to the wall, so near-wall air carries more momentum and climbs further up the adverse gradient. Separation moves aft, the wake narrows, and pressure drag falls, by about half (from memory), though skin friction rises: 11.5’s drag crisis, pulled down to golf-ball speeds.
Computing it
Block A also checks the rescaling trick of Problem 3: one shot at gives , and , the secant answer, with no iteration at all.
Graded: the residual’s sign on both sides of the root, to , the truncated answer, and the wing’s N/m.
Concept checks
Problems
Integrate from to to get the drag per unit span on one face. Show that , and evaluate the two-face drag of a m plate at m/s in sea-level air.
Show worked solution
, and , so . Dividing by : , twice the local at the trailing edge (the front, with its thin layer, rubs harder). With : one face N/m, two faces N/m, as in the lab. The singular at is integrable, and real leading edges are rounded anyway.
With , and , show that and that the boundary-layer equation becomes . Then show , and explain what its sign means for .
Show worked solution
and , so . With : , and , , , . In the terms cancel, leaving . Setting it equal to and dividing gives the equation. At , , so . For , : the profile curves upward at the wall but must curve downward as it approaches , so it has an inflection point (the sim marks it, at for ).
Show that if solves , so does for any . Use this to get from a single shot with that ends at .
Show worked solution
, , , and . So , and still. If has and , then has ; choose to make it . Then . Lab block A: , so . (The trick is usually credited to Töpfer, from memory; it works because Blasius has no length scale, and it fails for Falkner–Skan with , whose term does not scale the same way.)
Key Takeaways
- Prandtl: at high Re, viscosity acts only in a thin wall layer. Potential flow outside sets and ; inside, inertia balances , so , and pressure is constant across the layer.
- acts like time: a code can march the layer downstream until separation.
- A flat plate’s layer is one shape stretched by : Blasius, . Shooting on gives ; test the cut-off at ( gives , and agree to seven digits).
- , , ; the drag is the layer’s momentum deficit.
- The light wing at m/s: a laminar layer would be mm thick at the trailing edge and rub N/m off both faces, but reaches at m.
- An adverse gradient stops the slow near-wall air first: at the wall makes an inflection, then zero wall shear. Falkner–Skan separates at (): a slowdown per doubling of distance.
- Separation causes bluff-body pressure drag and wing stall; dimples trip a golf ball’s layer turbulent so it separates later.
- Next, 11.9: past (from memory) the laminar layer we just solved breaks down and the boundary layer becomes turbulent, a chaotic layer that mixes fast air down to the wall, rubs harder and holds on longer. Describing it takes averages, a closure problem and an energy cascade: turbulence.