Last lesson ended with a claim: at high Reynolds number viscosity lives in thin layers, and what they carry and spread is vorticity. Vorticity is also the answer to an aviator’s first question. In 11.3 Momentum: Pressure & the Euler Equations a cylinder had zero lift until we added a circulation by hand; then the lift was . Where does a wing get circulation, from air that started at rest? The starting vortex, Kelvin’s theorem and the trailing vortices are one bookkeeping rule.
Tools: 2.8 Curl & Vorticity, 2.9 Line Integrals, Circulation & Flux, 2.10 Green, Stokes & the Divergence Theorem, 11.4 Viscosity & the Navier–Stokes Equations and 4.3 Runge–Kutta Methods & Butcher Tableaux.
Transcript
- A wing sits on the runway in still air, so a big loop of air around it has zero circulation. In flight, lift is rho U times circulation. Where does that come from? By Kelvin the loop must still read zero, so as the wing accelerates, an opposite vortex peels off the trailing edge and stays behind: the starting vortex.
- Circulation is the loop integral of velocity, and by Stokes it equals the vorticity flux inside. A Rankine vortex has a solid core of radius one half metre and circulation ten: vorticity twelve point seven three two four, rim speed three point one eight three. A small circle in the core gives two point five. A square of side two around it gives ten point oh one oh six, ten point oh oh oh one, ten point oh oh oh oh oh one, as points per side grow from ten to a thousand. A square beside the core gives zero: no vorticity enclosed.
- Take the curl of Navier-Stokes. Time gives omega t. Pressure gives p y x minus p x y: zero, so pressure drops out. Viscosity becomes nu Laplacian omega, and advection leaves a divergence of u, also zero. In two dimensions vorticity is simply carried and diffused. In three, omega dot grad u stretches and tilts vortex lines, like a skater pulling in her arms. Two dimensions cannot stretch.
- Without a flow, vorticity obeys the heat equation, and its point-source solution is the Lamb-Oseen vortex. For a light-aircraft wingtip vortex, circulation eighteen point seven five in air, the core spreads from sixty-six point four to two hundred ten millimetres between one minute and ten, and the peak swirl falls from thirty-two point two to ten point two metres per second. But the circulation stays eighteen point seven five. Viscosity moves vorticity; it never destroys it.
- Kelvin: in inviscid flow every material loop keeps its circulation. And vorticity sets the velocity through Biot-Savart: each point vortex swirls Gamma over two pi r around itself. So N vortices are two N ODEs for RK4. A pair of opposite sign translates at Gamma over two pi d, zero point one five nine one five five. Two of the same sign waltz, with period nineteen point seven three nine two.
- Pairs one behind the other leapfrog. The faster inner pair shoots ahead, and the squeezed outer pair speeds up and slips through. The swaps come at two point eight four, five point six six, eight point four eight: every two point eight three time units, the group drifting at zero point two one one one.
- Point vortices are Hamiltonian. RK4 keeps circulation and impulse to round-off, since they are linear. But H is not, and RK4 is not symplectic, so H drifts: six point three seven times ten to the minus five at step zero point two, two point one two times ten to the minus six at zero point one. A factor of thirty.
- Now the aircraft. Bound circulation is half U c C L: eighteen point seven five square metres per second, lifting twelve thousand six hundred thirty-three newtons over eleven metres of span. The starting vortex waits on the runway, and by Helmholtz the bound vortex trails off each tip as a pair eight point six three nine metres apart, sinking at Gamma over two pi b prime: zero point three four five four metres per second. A heavy jet: six hundred eighty, sinking two point three oh.
- Away from boundary layers and the wake, vorticity is zero. Then velocity is a gradient, phi obeys Laplace's equation, and that is linear: flows can simply be added. Next lesson: potential flow, a cylinder, our vortex, and a wing from one complex function.
Vorticity and circulation
Vorticity is , in 2D the scalar : twice the spin rate of a tiny paddle wheel (11.1). The circulation around a closed curve is the line integral of the velocity along it,
and the second equality is Stokes’ theorem: circulation is the vorticity flux through any surface the loop bounds, measured from the boundary alone.
A Rankine vortex has a solid-body core of radius m, circulation m/s, and an irrotational swirl outside:
Inside, s; outside, is constant, so . The rim spins fastest, m/s. The lab integrates:
- A circle of radius inside the core: , the enclosed flux.
- A square of side around the core, midpoint rule with points per side: , , for , second-order convergence to . The loop’s shape does not matter, only the vorticity inside.
- A unit square beside the core, centred at : , zero. The air there moves in circles, yet encloses no vorticity.
The vorticity equation
Take the curl of Navier–Stokes. In 2D, the components are
differentiate the second in , the first in , and subtract. Term by term:
- Time: .
- Pressure: : mixed partials commute, (2.11 The Laplacian & Vector Identities). A gradient pushes a parcel without twisting it.
- Viscosity: derivatives commute with , so it becomes .
- Advection: the product rule gives plus , and the last bracket is .
What survives:
Vorticity is carried and diffused like heat, nothing more; with each parcel keeps its own, so the largest can never grow.
In 3D the same steps, with two vector identities (stated: and the curl of ), give
The new term, the change of velocity along the vortex line, does two things:
- Stretching. In the straining flow a vortex tube along gets , so . The tube lengthens like , its cross-section shrinks like , and its circulation stays fixed: a skater pulling in her arms spins faster.
- Tilting. Where the vertical speed varies with , feeds : vorticity is turned to point another way.
2D has neither. There and nothing depends on , so . Stretching drives the 3D energy cascade of 11.9; no 2D simulation can do it.
Vorticity diffuses: the Lamb–Oseen vortex
With no flow carrying it, is the heat equation: 11.4’s momentum diffusion, as vorticity. Its axisymmetric point-source solution is the Lamb–Oseen vortex:
The circulation inside radius is , which climbs to as at every time: viscosity moves vorticity outward without destroying it. The core spreads like ; the swirl peaks where is largest, , so the core radius is and the peak swirl .
Take a light-aircraft wingtip vortex, m/s (derived below), in air, m/s. The lab checks the PDE by central differences at cm, s: . Integrating gives at s and s, while the core grows from to mm and the peak swirl falls from to m/s. Molecular viscosity alone would leave a wake vortex swirling at m/s after a minute; real ones decay far faster, through turbulence and pair instabilities (from memory).
The sim runs finite volumes from m ( s) to m: minutes. Each face flux leaves one cell and enters the next, so the total circulation, on this grid, changes by about in steps. At the end the core radius is m exact, from the volumes; the peak swirl against m/s.
Kelvin’s circulation theorem
Follow a material loop , made of fluid particles.
The mechanism: each element is a material fibre, which changes at the velocity difference across it (11.1), . Then
Euler’s equation (gravity potential ) gave the middle step; every term integrates an exact differential ( when depends on alone) around a closed loop, giving zero. Only what was excluded can change it: viscosity, density not set by pressure alone, non-conservative forces.
From Kelvin come the Helmholtz vortex theorems (stated, same assumptions):
- Vortex lines are material: fluid on one stays on one. Mechanism: a small loop drawn on the side of a vortex tube encloses no vorticity flux ( is tangent there), so its circulation is zero; by Kelvin it stays zero, so the loop stays on the tube.
- A vortex tube’s circulation is the same at every cross-section () and constant in time.
- A vortex tube cannot end in the fluid: it closes, ends on a boundary, or runs to infinity.
The green loop, tracers refined as it stretches, starts at (chords cut corners) and reads at on points. In the leapfrog preset it hits its -point cap near , still at ; then the polygon fails, not Kelvin.
Biot–Savart and point vortices
Since and , vorticity determines velocity (plus boundary conditions) through the Biot–Savart law, borrowed from magnetism. In 3D, stated: . In 2D each bit of vorticity induces a swirl around itself.
For point vortices , the velocity sums their swirls:
Vorticity is carried (2D, ), so each vortex moves with the velocity the others induce at it: ODEs for RK4. This is the simplest vortex method, vorticity on moving particles with no grid at all (viscosity can enter as a random walk, Chorin’s method, from memory).
The pair. above , distance apart. Each induces at the other, in the same direction, so the pair translates rigidly at
The velocities never change, so RK4 is exact: the sim reads .
Same sign. Two vortices each move at on a circle of radius , so and the period is ; the sim measures .
Leapfrogging. Pairs at and : the faster inner pair shoots ahead, where the outer pair’s flow spreads and slows it while it squeezes the outer pair, which speeds up and passes through. The sim logs the swaps at (first step after each): every time units, the group drifting at . Smoke rings do it in 3D (from memory).
The ground. An image vortex at per real one cancels the flow through the wall . A pair started at height descends at (free: ), slows, and runs apart along the ground at nearly , about . Problem 2 shows each follows const, here , so the height tends to ; the sim holds the constant to .
Where a wing’s circulation comes from
A wing sits on the runway in still air; a large material loop around it has . The wing accelerates and lifts. Outside the thin boundary layers the air is inviscid, so by Kelvin the loop, which never touches the skin, still has . Yet a lifting wing has circulation. The books balance because a vortex of opposite circulation peels off the sharp trailing edge and stays behind: the starting vortex. With flow left to right and lift up, the bound circulation is clockwise, the starting vortex counterclockwise, summing to zero. Viscosity in the boundary layer makes the vorticity; the sharp trailing edge decides how much (the Kutta condition, 12.1).
How much? Equate Kutta–Joukowski’s lift per unit span (11.3) with :
for 11.5’s light-aircraft wing, chord m, m/s, . Over an m span that lifts N, roughly a loaded four-seater (from memory). The starting vortex, m/s, sits near the start of the take-off roll.
By Helmholtz’s third theorem the bound vortex cannot stop at the wingtips: it trails behind each tip back to the starting vortex, one closed loop. The trailing legs are the wingtip vortices. Seen from behind they are a pair, left clockwise, right counterclockwise, and like any pair they translate, here downward. With the trailing sheet rolled up into cores m apart (elliptic loading, from memory), the sink rate is
and the wing preset measures m/s, m in s. (A crude model: N, of the lift; good to twenty percent.)
A heavy jet on approach, t at m/s with a m span: m/s, sinking at m/s, m in two minutes. Hence the several miles, or two to three minutes, that controllers put behind a heavy aircraft (from memory). Near the ground (the ground preset) the pair stops sinking at about half its spacing and runs outward at roughly its old sink rate, toward a parallel runway.
Computing it
Graded: velocities to (three unequal vortices catch sign slips), the pair at to , the impulse to , drift below at and ten times below . Total circulation is trivially kept here; on a grid 11.11 must earn it.
Concept checks
Problems
Two point vortices are a distance apart. (a) For , find the translation speed. (b) For two , find the period of rotation. Evaluate for .
Show worked solution
(a) Each vortex feels the other’s swirl, , perpendicular to the line joining them. For opposite signs both point the same way: the pair translates at , unchanged forever. (b) For equal signs they are opposite: each moves at on a circle of radius , so and the period is . The sim’s pair and co-rotation presets print and .
A pair, at and at , descends toward a wall at . Use images and the conservation of to show that stays constant, and find the final height when the pair starts at , .
Show worked solution
The images, at and at , make a free four-vortex system that stays a rectangle and conserves . The six pairs: two at distance (real pair, image pair) with product ; two at distance (each vortex with its image) with product ; two diagonals at , , with product . So
Constant means constant , that is, constant . At the start that is . As the vortices run apart, and . The ground preset holds the constant to and shows the height at .
(a) Find the Lamb–Oseen circulation inside radius . (b) Show the swirl peaks at . (c) Find at s in air.
Show worked solution
(a) , using ; it tends to at every . (b) With , ; its derivative vanishes when , at (numerically). (c) m, so m, as the lab prints.
Key Takeaways
- Circulation is the loop integral of velocity, equal to the vorticity flux inside (Stokes): , and for loops inside, around and beside a Rankine core.
- The curl of Navier–Stokes removes pressure: in 2D, plus stretching and tilting in 3D only.
- Viscosity diffuses vorticity without destroying it: the Lamb–Oseen core grows like , the circulation stays m/s.
- Kelvin: inviscid barotropic flow keeps the circulation of every material loop. Helmholtz: vortex lines move with the fluid and cannot end in it.
- Biot–Savart turns vorticity into velocity; point vortices make it ODEs. Pairs move at , equal vortices waltz with period , coaxial pairs leapfrog. RK4 keeps the impulse exactly and lets drift: at , at .
- A wing’s bound circulation, m/s, is balanced by the starting vortex on the runway, joined to it by trailing vortices sinking at m/s (a heavy jet’s: m/s).
- Next, 11.7: outside boundary layers and wakes the vorticity is zero, so with . That is linear: superpose a stream, a cylinder and our point vortex, map the cylinder to an airfoil with one complex function, and Laplace’s equation alone gives a wing its lift.