Last lesson’s mm film of air, sheared at m/s, had Reynolds number . It carried a viscosity, a speed and a gap, three numbers with units, and the claim was that only one combination of them matters. That claim is what makes wind tunnels possible. An aircraft maker does not build a new wing full size to learn how it stalls; it puts a model a few percent of full size in a tunnel and trusts that the air around the model is doing the same thing. This lesson says exactly when that trust is justified.
The tools are ones you already own: Navier–Stokes from 11.4 Viscosity & the Navier–Stokes Equations, Bernoulli and dynamic pressure from 11.3 Momentum: Pressure & the Euler Equations, and, for the cleverest step, the kernel of a matrix from 1.3 Linear Systems, Kernel & Column Space.
Transcript
- A one millimetre film of air, sheared at fifty metres per second, has Reynolds number three thousand four hundred twenty-three. In water, three point four two three metres per second gives the same number. The stresses differ: zero point eight nine five pascals against three point four two three. But divide each by rho U squared and both give two point nine two one four times ten to the minus four: exactly one over Re. In dimensionless clothes, the two films are one flow.
- Why? Measure lengths in L, speeds in U, time in L over U, pressure in rho U squared. The time derivative, the advection and the pressure all become U squared over L; the viscous term becomes nu U over L squared. Divide through by U squared over L and the only leftover is nu over U L: one over Re in front of the viscous term. Same shape, same boundary data, same Re: the same equation, the same flow. That is dynamic similarity.
- Is Re really a ratio of forces? Measure it on an exact solution, the Taylor-Green cell, a checkerboard of counter-rotating vortices. Pressure alone balances the inertia, and the viscous term just drains the vortices. Their root-mean-square ratio is Re over two root two: zero point zero three five four at Re zero point one, thirty-five point four at one hundred, thirty-five thousand three hundred fifty-five at ten to the fifth. The inertia line stays put; the viscous line drops a decade per decade.
- Real flows span enormous Re. A ten micron cloud droplet, falling at three millimetres per second, is two point one times ten to the minus three: creeping, reversible Stokes flow. A honeybee wing is one point zero three times ten to the third; a light-aircraft wing five point one three five million; an airliner thirty-two million. There, viscosity survives only in a layer of thickness L over root Re: zero point six six two millimetres on the light wing.
- Other physics, other ratios. Mach is speed over sound speed: density changes by about M squared over two, four point five percent at Mach point three. Froude, U over root g L, brings gravity in as one over Froude squared; for the light wing Froude is thirteen point oh three, so gravity is under one percent of inertia. Strouhal, f L over U, is about zero point two for a cylinder, so a five millimetre wire at thirty metres per second sings at twelve hundred hertz.
- What if you only know which variables matter? Drag on a sphere depends on F, rho, U, D and mu. Write each as a vector of mass, length and time exponents: a product is dimensionless when A times n is zero. The groups are the kernel of the dimension matrix; rank three, five variables, so two groups. The kernel is spanned by one, minus one, minus two, minus two, zero and zero, minus one, minus one, minus one, one. Multiplying checks both. They are F over rho U squared D squared, and one over Re: one curve.
- Now a wind tunnel. A one to ten model of the light wing needs ten times the speed to match Re: five hundred metres per second, Mach one point four seven, shock waves, a different flow. Every escape lowers the tunnel's viscosity: water needs only thirty-four point two three, air at ten atmospheres fifty. The one to twenty airliner must match Mach and Re together. In sea-level air, Mach point eight four seven means two hundred eighty-eight point three metres per second but only four point nine three five million Re, short by six point four eight. At one hundred ten kelvin, Mach needs just one hundred seventy-eight point one four, and one point seven oh nine atmospheres gives the full Re.
- So Re is the one dial. When it is large, one over Re says viscosity vanishes, yet no-slip keeps it alive in a thin layer. What does it spread there? Next lesson: take the curl of Navier-Stokes and pressure disappears, leaving one quantity carried by the flow and spread by viscosity: vorticity. Boundary layers are sheets of it; wakes are where it goes.
Units are a choice; physics is ratios
Metres and seconds are human conventions the air does not know, so a true law must survive a change of units. Only dimensionless combinations do.
Try it on the film. With this lesson’s air properties (the ISA model, formulas from memory, giving m/s at sea level against 11.4’s rounded ),
The third digit moved with the property table, not the physics. Now replace the air by water, . The same Re needs m/s. The stresses differ: Pa in air, Pa in water. Divide each by , though, and both give , which is exactly . In dimensionless clothes the two films are one flow.
Scaling Navier–Stokes
Pick a length (a chord, a gap), a speed (the free stream), and define starred variables, each of order one in the region that matters:
is the time a parcel takes to pass the body; is twice 11.3’s dynamic pressure, the pressure change inertia can produce. Now convert each term of
A derivative in is , so and . Term by term:
Divide everything by . Three terms come out clean; the last keeps the factor :
Continuity, , loses its constant altogether.
Re as a ratio of forces, measured
The estimate behind the name: inertia per unit mass is about , viscous force about , and their ratio is . “About” hides a shape-dependent factor, so let us measure it on a real flow.
The Taylor–Green cell is an exact Navier–Stokes solution, a checkerboard of counter-rotating vortices (verifying it is the first problem):
At , direct differentiation gives two clean facts. The inertia is , which is exactly : here pressure alone holds the inertia, as in Euler’s equations. And , so the viscous term just drains the vortices, .
Average the squares over a cell: averages to , so the inertia has RMS , and the viscous term . The ratio is
Re is the ratio, up to a factor belonging to this shape. Central differences on a grid measure and instead of and , ratio at : second-order errors of a tenth of a percent.
Slide Re: the arrows never change; only the viscous line drops, a decade per decade, crossing the inertia line at . The amplitude falls by at . At that is : the vortices die before a parcel has moved a twentieth of . At the cell survives passage times.
The two limits
Creeping flow, Re ≪ 1
Small Re makes the viscous term huge, so the pressure scale is now wrong: pressure must balance viscosity, not inertia. Multiply the starred equation by Re and define :
These are the Stokes equations: linear, with no time derivative, so the flow at each instant is fixed by the boundary velocities at that instant. Flip the sign of every boundary velocity and solves the new problem, so a parcel retraces its path exactly when the walls retrace theirs: creeping flow is reversible (G. I. Taylor’s glycerine demonstration, from memory).
The classic result (from memory, derived in many texts) is Stokes drag on a sphere, . A micron cloud droplet falls when that drag equals its weight, , so mm/s, and its Re is .
High Re: viscosity hides in thin layers
At the factor looks like permission to drop viscosity, leaving Euler. But Euler cannot meet no-slip, and 11.4 showed that dropping the highest derivative loses a boundary condition. The way out: near the wall the velocity changes over a thickness much smaller than , so there is not of order one but of order . The viscous term becomes , and it rejoins the balance when that is of order one:
For a light-aircraft wing, chord m at m/s, and mm. 11.4’s impulsive-plate estimate, at the trailing edge, gives mm: the same law, , with a constant in front. Small coefficient, huge derivative: that product is where skin friction, separation and stall live (11.8).
Mach, Froude, Strouhal, and real aircraft
Other physics brings other ratios, each a comparison of two terms.
Mach, . Bernoulli changes the pressure by about . A gas answers with a density change (, the sound speed squared; a preview of 11.12). So . At Mach that is : the conventional edge of “incompressible”.
Froude, . Add to Navier–Stokes, divide by , and it arrives as . It matters at a free surface: ship waves, a seaplane float. For the light wing : gravity’s term is under of inertia.
Strouhal, . When the flow has its own frequency , the time scale is , and the unsteady term carries St instead of . A cylinder sheds vortices alternately at (from memory, for Re from a few hundred to about ; the wind-tunnel capstone will measure it). A mm antenna wire at m/s, Re , sings at Hz.
| Flyer | , | Re | Mach |
|---|---|---|---|
| Light-aircraft wing, sea level | m, m/s | ||
| Airliner wing, km () | m, m/s | ||
| Honeybee wing (rough, from memory) | mm, m/s | ||
| Golf ball (from memory) | mm, m/s |
Bee and airliner differ by four decades of Re: a bee wing is not a small airliner wing.
The Re bands are for a flat-plate boundary layer with Re built on distance from the leading edge; their edges (, ) are from memory and move with roughness and free-stream turbulence. With them, the light wing’s layer should start transition about m behind the leading edge.
Buckingham π: the groups are a kernel
What if you know only the list of variables, not the equations? The drag on a sphere can depend on , , and , and nothing else (no gravity, no compressibility). Write a candidate group and demand it be dimensionless.
Each variable has a dimension vector in (mass, length, time): is kg m s, so ; is ; is ; is ; , Pa s kg m s, is . Exponents add when you multiply, so the group is dimensionless exactly when
Columns are ; rows are M, L, T. The dimensionless groups are the kernel of the dimension matrix. has rank , so the kernel has dimension : two independent groups. That count is the Buckingham π theorem.
Solve with and free. Row M: . Row T: . Row L: . So
Check by multiplying. : row M ; row L ; row T . And : M ; L ; T . Both squash to zero.
The first is , a force coefficient; the second is . Every physical law relating the five variables can be written . With the conventional factors,
Five variables became one curve. In creeping flow Stokes drag fills it in: . At high Re the curve flattens to a value of order one, then drops sharply in the drag crisis, at a Re of a few for a smooth sphere (from memory). The golf ball sits at , just below it; its dimples exist to pull the crisis down to where it flies (11.8).
Dynamic similarity in the wind tunnel
Test the light wing at , chord m, in sea-level air. Matching Re needs , so
Shock waves: a different flow. This is the central problem of wind-tunnel testing, and every escape lowers :
- Pressurize. barely depends on pressure (from memory), and , so . At atm, falls tenfold and m/s matches.
- Use water. m/s, and Mach is irrelevant (sound in water is about m/s, from memory). But no compressible effect of the aircraft can be reproduced at all.
- Cool the gas. Cold gas is denser and less viscous (Sutherland’s law).
The airliner shows why cold wins. At its chord is m and it must match Mach as well as . In sea-level air, matching Mach means m/s, which gives only , short by a factor . At K the sound speed drops to m/s, Mach needs only m/s, and the gas reaches the full-scale Re at atm. Cryogenic pressurized tunnels exist for precisely this (NASA’s National Transonic Facility and the European Transonic Windtunnel use cold nitrogen, from memory; the sim uses air properties).
Sometimes no fluid can match everything. A seaplane float at , m/s full scale, in a towing tank of water: Froude matching (waves) demands m/s, Reynolds matching m/s. Naval architects match Froude and correct for the missing factor in Re with friction formulas (from memory), accepting a known error over an impossible test.
Computing it
Exponents are graded to , the water speed to m/s; a pendulum matrix (period, length, , mass) catches hard-coded answers.
Concept checks
Problems
Check that the Taylor–Green cell satisfies the starred Navier–Stokes equations and continuity.
Show worked solution
Write , , (stars dropped). Continuity: .
Inertia, -component: . Pressure, : , equal to the inertia, as the balance requires. Viscous: , and . The -component works the same way. Every term balances, at every Re (the lab’s block C measures the sizes).
In creeping flow inertia is gone, so density cannot appear. (a) Write the dimension matrix for , find its kernel and show . (b) With , show .
Show worked solution
(a) Columns , , , . Rank , four columns: one group. For : M gives ; T gives ; L gives . With : , , . Check: M , L , T . So is a constant. Note what happened: losing removed a column, the kernel shrank to one vector, and the unknown function became a constant.
(b) .
A model of a m chord flying at Mach and is tested in air at K, where m/s and, at atm, m/s. Find the speed that matches Mach and the pressure that then matches Re.
Show worked solution
m/s. Required . Since at fixed , atm. The model panel, airliner at , K, prints atm, and at that pressure the Re line crosses the Mach line at .
Key Takeaways
- Physical laws relate dimensionless numbers. The mm film is in air at m/s and in water at m/s, with the same .
- Scaling by , , , leaves : same shape and Re, same flow.
- Re is inertia over viscosity: in the Taylor–Green cell the RMS ratio is , from to .
- Re ≪ 1: Stokes equations, linear and reversible, ; a micron droplet falls at mm/s.
- Re ≫ 1: viscosity survives in layers , mm on a light wing.
- Mach (), Froude and Strouhal compare other pairs of terms; the light wing is , the airliner at Mach .
- Buckingham π: the groups are the kernel of the dimension matrix; for sphere drag, .
- Matching Re at in air needs m/s; pressure, water or cold gas rescue it, and a cold tunnel at atm matches the airliner’s Re and Mach together.
- Next, 11.6: at high Re the viscous term lives only in thin layers, but what does it diffuse there? Take the curl of Navier–Stokes and pressure disappears, leaving one quantity that is carried by the flow and spread by viscosity: vorticity. Boundary layers are sheets of it, and wakes and wingtip vortices are where it goes.